Best Fandom Merch Stores and Collectible Shops in New York City, NY

🍜 Hungry after shopping? Check out our guide to the best fandom restaurants in New York City.

NYC is a fandom shopping mecca. From massive comic stores to hidden manga gems, the city offers more collectible-hunting opportunities per square mile than anywhere else in the country.

1. Forbidden Planet NYC — Broadway, Union Square

📍 Address: 832 Broadway, Manhattan, NY 10003

One of the largest and longest-running sci-fi, comic, and fantasy stores in the US. Three floors packed with graphic novels, manga, action figures, Funko Pops, board games, and indie comics. The manga section rivals specialty Japanese bookstores. New releases hit the shelves every Wednesday.

2. Kinokuniya Bookstore — Bryant Park, Midtown

📍 Address: 1073 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10018

Japan’s legendary bookstore chain has a massive NYC location with an entire floor dedicated to manga, anime art books, and Japanese stationery. The selection of original Japanese-language manga is unmatched in the US. They also carry exclusive Studio Ghibli merchandise and anime-themed gifts.

3. Nintendo NY — Rockefeller Center

📍 Address: 10 Rockefeller Plaza, New York, NY 10020

The official Nintendo flagship store — two floors of Mario, Zelda, Pokémon, Splatoon, and Animal Crossing merchandise. Playable demo stations, exclusive NYC-branded items, and a giant Mario statue greeting you at the entrance. The exclusive NYC t-shirts and pins are collector favorites.

4. Midtown Comics — Times Square / Grand Central / Downtown

📍 Address: 200 W 40th St, New York, NY 10018

NYC’s go-to comic book shop with three locations. The Times Square flagship is enormous, with a huge back-issue selection, signed editions, and exclusive variant covers. Regular signing events with comic book artists and writers. The staff actually knows their stuff.

5. Image Anime — West 33rd Street, Midtown

📍 Address: 242 W 30th St, Manhattan, NY 10001

A hidden gem near Penn Station specializing in anime figures, model kits, Gundam, and imported Japanese collectibles. The figure selection — from prize figures to high-end scales — rivals what you’d find in Akihabara. Prices are competitive with online retailers.

Plan Your New York City Fandom Shopping Trip

The best fandom merch can’t be found online — it’s in these shops, waiting to be discovered. Add these stores to your next New York City itinerary and bring an extra suitcase for the haul.

Need flights and hotels in New York City? Search deals on Expedia and start planning your fandom shopping trip today.